Imo Gov'ship judgment: S' Court dismisses Ihedioha, PDP's application — Daily Times Nigeria

Imo Gov’ship judgment: S’ Court dismisses Ihedioha, PDP’s application


.Apex Court’s  verdict, endorsement of electoral fraud, says PDP

.APC congratulates Uzodinma, says electoral, judicial reforms expedient

The Supreme Court on Tuesday laid to rest the controversies surrounding the request to reverse its January 14, 2020 decision by affirming the judgment.

In a six to one split ruling, the apex court held that the application brought by  Emeka Ihedioha and Peoples Democratic Party  PDP lacked merit.


The Apex Court further held that it lacked powers to sit on appeal in its own judgment delivered on merit and in accordance with dictates of the law and justice.

The court held that the request by Ihedioha asking it to set aside its judgment of January 14 this year on grounds of nullity is an invitation on the apex court to sit on appeal over its own judgment, which the court cannot do.

Lagos Assembly passes ‘Amotekun’ bill into law

In the majority ruling delivered by Justice Olukayode Ariwoola, the court held that granting the request of the applicants would open the flood gate by parties to all kinds of litigations.

The apex court in the majority ruling insisted that by the provision of section 235 of the 1999 Constitution, its decision on any judgment based on merit is final and shall not be reviewed once delivered under any guise, except for clerical errors.

The court also stated that by Order 8 Rule 16, the general law is that it has no power to alter any judgment and that such judgment once delivered on merit shall remain forever.

Justice Ariwoola said: “Certainly this court has no inherent power to grant what is being sought, it is beyond the powers of this Court. There is no Constitutional provisions for this court to review its own judgment.

“To say the least, this court has no competence and indeed lacked power to sit on appeal in its own decision. Finality of the Supreme Court is entrenched in the constitution and inherent power can only be invoked were there is law to do so.

“This court cannot under any guise alter any judgment under any inherent power, as doing so would bring the court into disrepute and ridicle.

“The application is liable to dismissal and is hereby dismissed for want of jurisdiction and competence.

The court however held that parties in this case should bear their cost.

The Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Ibrahim Muhammad, Justices Sylvester Ngwuta, Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, Amina Augie and Mary Uwani Abba-Aji agreed with the lead ruling.

Justice Centus Chima Nweze, however in his dissenting ruling, set aside the January 14 judgment of the Supreme Court that removed Ihedioha from office as a nullity and in bad faith.

Justice Nweze, who nullified the declaration of Uzodinma as governor on account of wrong declaration, held that Uzodinma mischievously misled the court into unjust conclusion with the unverified votes credited to himself in the disputed 388 polling units.

“In my intimate reading of the January 14 judgment, the meat and substance of Ihedioha’s matter were lost to time frame. This Court once set aside its own earlier judgment and therefore cannot use time frame to extinguish the right of any person.

“This Court has powers to over rule itself and can revisit any decision not in accordance with justice”, he said.

According to Justice Nweze, the decision of the Supreme Court in the instant matter will continue to hunt our electoral jurisprudence for a long time to come, adding that without evidence of meeting other constitutional provisions, the court misled itself into declaring Uzodinma as governor.

“This Court has a duty of redeeming its image, it is against this background that the finality of the Court cannot extinguish the right of any person.

“I am of the view that this application should succeed. I hereby make an order setting aside the decision of this Court made on January 14 and that the certificate of return issued to the appeallant be returned to INEC.

“I also make an order restoring the respondents as winner of the March 9, 2019 governorship election.

Reacting, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) said Tuesday’s verdict of the Supreme Court on the review of its judgment on the Imo State governorship election is a disconcerting endorsement of electoral fraud, which places a huge burden on the court and the Lord Justices.

The PDP however noted that in the face of the said verdict, Justice Chima Nweze’s judgment presents a glimpse of hope for our nation’s judiciary.

This position was contained in a statement on Tuesday by party’s spokesperson, Kola Ologbondiyan.

 Agreeing  completely with every word of the judgment of Justice Nweze as treated facts, which it said,  are truly sacred, the PDP said “Justice Nweze’s pronouncement, which went straight into the substance of our application represents a universal view about the travesty of justice that occurred in the Imo State governorship election judgment.

“It is indeed unfortunate that the Supreme Court had the wholesome opportunity to redeem itself and correct its errors, but chose to hide behind technicality to justify and endorse an electoral fraud”.

The party said the apex court by its verdict disappointed millions of Nigerians who had expected it, since the error in its earlier judgment had been fully established, to summon the courage to affirm its infallibility by correcting the errors and handing over victory to the rightful winner.

“For the avoidance of doubt, what the Supreme Court had done in this judgment is to uphold and legalize the writing of election results by individual contestants against the will of the people as expressed at the poll.

“As a party, we hold that on this judgment, all election stakeholders must rally to create remedies for this pathetic situation created by the Supreme Court in the Imo governorship election before our entire electoral process becomes vanquished.

“This judgment will continue to haunt the Supreme Court. It has created a burden of precedence and fallibility on the Court.

“More distressing is the fact that the judgment has heavily detracted from the confidence Nigerians and the international community reposed on the Supreme Court and our entire jurisprudence”, the party submitted.

Meanwhile, the All Progressives Congress (APC) has congratulated the Imo State Governor, Senator Hope Uzodinma, on the Supreme Court’s affirmation of his 2019 election victory following the apex court’s review of its earlier decision.

This notwithstanding, the party canvassed an urgent reformation of Nigeria’s electoral and judicial process to sanitise the polity.

Reacting to the Supreme Court verdict, the APC in a statement by its national publicity secretary, Lanre Issa – Onilu, said as a law-abiding party, it believes in the sanctity of the rule of law and will always accept the decisions of courts, whether favourable or not.

“The APC will never chose the route of impugning on the integrity of our Judiciary, undermining other public institutions and threatening our democracy with unpatriotic utterances and actions.

“However, recent developments in the polity has made electoral and judicial reforms a matter of urgency and necessity. These are the tasks before the 9th National Assembly as it embarks on the Constitution Review exercise.

“We are confident the Imo people have chosen the right man for the job. Our congratulations therefore goes to the good people of Imo State as they begin a new journey into prosperity under the capable watch of Governor Uzodinma”, the party stated.

About the author

Our Correspondent

Leave a Comment